Smoked Brisket

This article was inspired by OTFC contributor Nick Hill of Salt & Fire BBQ.

Why This Smoked Brisket Recipe Works

There are hundreds of brisket recipes out there. Some are overly complicated, others are too simple to produce the results you want. This one hits the sweet spot — a simple recipe that delivers consistent texture, deep smoky flavor, and a bark you can knock on. It works on any setup, whether you’re cooking on an offset using indirect heat, a pellet grill, or a charcoal smoker loaded with dry wood and a few wood chips.

You’ll learn the entire process, including the best way to trim, season, smoke, rest, and slice your brisket based on real-world experience — not just a temperature probe number. I’ve cooked briskets in every style imaginable, from overnight long cooks on a drum to mid-day quick hits on a pellet smoker. The principles I walk you through here are built to flex with your gear, your heat source, and your personal preference.

And if you screw up your first brisket? That’s a rite of passage. Every pitmaster has been there.

Tools, Ingredients & Prep for Smoked Brisket

To do this right, you’ll need the right tools. A reliable meat thermometer or temperature probe is essential for checking the internal temperature of the meat. You’ll also need a sharp knife — ideally a boning or slicing knife — a sturdy cutting board, and a good roll of pink butcher paper. A small bowl for your dry rub mix and a spray bottle for your spritz will make things easier.

Start with a full packer brisket, which includes both the flat cut and the point. I prefer one in the 12- to 14-pound range. You’ll also need yellow mustard as a binder, kosher salt, 16-mesh coarse black pepper, and granulated garlic. Some folks also add garlic powder and onion powder to their rubs — both are solid additions if that fits your flavor profile.

For wrapping, I like to pour on warm tallow before sealing the beef brisket in butcher paper. And for spritzing, I go with a 50/50 mix of apple cider vinegar and water, though apple juice or even watered-down hot sauce can add an extra layer of flavor.

Choosing the Right Beef Brisket

Picking out a beef brisket isn’t just grabbing the biggest hunk of meat in the bin and calling it good. You’re about to spend the next 10–14 hours of your life with this piece of meat, so it’s worth taking a minute to choose the right one.

Now, not every little flaw is a dealbreaker — sometimes you sacrifice a slightly thinner flat to get better marbling, or overlook a rough trim job if the rest of the cut checks out. But once a brisket starts stacking up red flags? I put it back and keep digging.

And don’t be shy — ask the meat department if they’ve got more in the back. I’ve done it more times than I can count, even when there were five “perfectly good” briskets sitting right in front of me. Trust me, making friends with your butcher is one of the best moves you can make as a backyard pitmaster.

what To look for when choosing a brisket:

First, check the fat cap

• If the packer got a little wild with the blade and sliced too deep, exposing the meat beneath, it’s not ideal — especially when you’re aiming to keep moisture in during the cook. Then flip it over and check for marbling in the flat. You want to see white flecks running with the grain. No marbling in a choice brisket is common, but with Prime, it should at least be visible. Wagyu will have the most, though I personally find it a bit too rich for a long smoke.

Next, look at the flat

• Thickness matters. If the flat cut is too thin — less than an inch of muscle once you account for trimming — that meat is gonna dry out before it ever gets tender. You’ll also end up trimming off more than you should, which just wastes your money. I’m always hunting for the thickest, most even flat I can find.

The Bend Test

• Some folks say a bendy brisket equals a tender final product. Not quite. A floppy brisket might just mean it has a thinner fat cap or a smaller deckle. Or it could just mean looser muscle fibers. None of those automatically guarantees a better result. Still, it’s useful — if the brisket is super stiff, that probably means you’ll be trimming a ton of thick, dense fat and maybe dealing with a deckle that won’t render out. So yes, I still look for some pliability — but I use it as a guide, not gospel.

Lastly, don’t assume bigger is better!

• Some of the worst cooks I’ve had came from monster 18- to 20-pound briskets that were a pain to manage. I’ll take two well-shaped 12- to 14-pounders any day over one giant. You’ll get better airflow, better bark, and less waste.

How to Trim Your Beef Brisket

Start with cold meat straight from the fridge. Cold meat is easier to trim, and it helps you feel the difference between fat and muscle fibers. Place the brisket fat side down on a large cutting board and trim off any loose flaps of fat or thin meat that won’t cook evenly.

Round off the thin flat end until the remaining muscle is at least an inch thick — otherwise, that part will dry out. Trim the deckle fat carefully without cutting into the meat side. Then flip the brisket and tackle the fat cap side, trimming it down to a uniform quarter inch across the entire surface of the brisket. Think aerodynamic — you want smooth edges so air and smoke flow evenly across the meat during the smoking process.

If you see large bands of fat on the surface of the brisket that feel dense or solid, trim them down. Fatty side or not, thick fat doesn’t render well and will ruin your bark.

Seasoning and Binding the Brisket

Use yellow mustard as a binder. It helps your dry rub stick to the brisket and doesn’t affect the taste once cooked. If mustard’s not your thing, try olive oil, Worcestershire sauce, or hot sauce. That part is all personal preference.

My dry rub is simple: kosher salt, coarse black pepper, and granulated garlic. You can also add garlic powder or onion powder if you want to round out the flavor. Some folks mix in a little brown sugar, but I skip it — sugar can burn during long cook times.

Mix your rub in a small bowl and apply it heavily to all sides of the brisket. Don’t be shy. You want the brisket to look like it’s wearing a pepper jacket.

If you can’t eat the whole brisket at once, consider turning the leftovers into a Chopped Brisket Sandwich, Smoked Brisket Queso, BBQ Brisket Nachos, Smoked Texas Twinkies or Leftover Brisket Breakfast Skillet!

Smoking the Brisket

Preheat your smoker to 250 to 275 degrees Fahrenheit. Whether you’re using a pellet smoker or an offset rig with wood chips and dry wood, aim for indirect heat and steady airflow. Place the brisket fat cap up, with the point end toward the heat source.

Once it’s on the smoker, leave it alone for the first four hours. That bark needs time to form. After that, start spritzing the surface of the brisket every 45 minutes or so. A 50/50 mix of apple cider vinegar and water works great, but apple juice or even diluted beef broth can do the job too.

Cook time will vary based on your heat source and the brisket size. But here’s the general flow: keep spritzing until the bark is well developed and you’re seeing a dark, rich color. For me, that’s usually around 170 to 180 degrees internal temp. That’s when it’s time to wrap.

Double Wrap the smoked Brisket

Lay out two full-length sheets of pink butcher paper. If you’re out of paper, aluminum foil works too — that’s the Texas crutch, and it’s a good backup if you’re running behind on time or need to salvage a bark that got away from you.

Before wrapping, I pour warmed beef tallow over the top of the brisket. It adds moisture and helps create a rich bark crust. Wrap the brisket tightly with two full rolls, keeping the fat side up. Tuck in the corners to make sure everything is sealed.

Place the wrapped brisket back in the smoker with the flat side facing the heat source. Keep smoking until your meat thermometer glides into the flat with almost no resistance. That usually happens between 200 and 208 degrees Fahrenheit.

Resting the Brisket (Don’t Skip This)

Once the brisket is probe tender, pull it from the smoker and place brisket on a cutting board or sheet tray to cool at room temperature. Let it rest for about a half hour until the internal temperature of the meat drops to 180 to 185 degrees.

Then transfer it into an empty cooler. I don’t usually add towels unless I need to hold it for a long time. Rest it until the internal temp comes down to around 140 degrees Fahrenheit. That long rest is where the magic happens. The muscle fibers relax, the moisture reabsorbs, and the bark stabilizes. If you skip this step, you’ll end up with a dry brisket and a missed opportunity.

Slicing and Serving

Once rested, unwrap the brisket and place it fat side down on your cutting board. Start slicing across the grain of the flat in quarter-inch slices. When you reach the point — where the muscle fibers shift direction — rotate the brisket 90 degrees and continue slicing. Slightly thicker cuts work best for the point.

Properly cooked, the beef brisket slices will hold together under their own weight and bend easily. If they fall apart, it’s overcooked. If they resist and feel chewy, it’s undercooked. Learn from each cook and adjust.

Serve with your favorite barbecue sauce, white bread, or pickled red onions. Two to three slices per guest is usually enough, especially if you’re also serving pork shoulder, sausage, or sides.

Leftovers and Storage

If you somehow have any brisket left, wrap it in foil or transfer it to an airtight container and refrigerate for up to five days. For freezing, vacuum sealing gives you the best results. Reheat slowly — low oven or gentle steam — to preserve that bark and avoid drying it out.

Leftover brisket makes killer burnt ends, brisket breakfast hash, or even tacos. You worked hard for it. Use every piece.

A FINAL WORD ON BEEF BRISKET

There’s no shortcut to great brisket, but it doesn’t have to be a mystery either. Learn your smoker, trust your senses, and don’t obsess over numbers. Feel the resistance. Watch the surface of the brisket. Smell the wood. And remember, every brisket teaches you something. That’s the beauty of it.

Next time, try this same method on a pork shoulder or give one of my hot and fast brisket cooks a go. Whether you’re running a long cook or testing new rubs, there’s always a new variable to dial in.

Good luck and happy smoking!

FAQs for Smoked Beef Brisket

More Brisket

Hot and Fast Smoked Brisket Recipe

Easy Smoked Brisket

Mesquite Peppercorn Lager Smoked Brisket

Leftover Brisket Breakfast Skillet

Texas Smoked Brisket Recipe

Brisket Burnt Ends